I haven't watched Gilmore Girls so I can't compare. How old is your daughter? I watch
Gossip Girl with LurkieGirl (she's 17 now

) or we watch it separately and talk about things. It's very over the top...lots of teenage sex & underage drinking among the rich folks of the Upper East side of NYC. There are times that I get uncomfortable watching it with her...but it is a great conversation starter about teenage behavior.
Hopefully someone who has watched Gilmore Girls will post & give you their opinion.
Good to see you around the boards again

How old is the littlest Spring these days?